Tuesday, August 9, 2022
Subscriber Login
My Profile
SpotlightNews
  • Home
  • News
    • Business
      • Spotlight On Business
      • Spotlight on Finance
    • Crime
    • Discover-Towns
      • Discover Coeymans Selkirk and Feura Bush
      • Discover Delmar
      • Discover Glenmont
      • Discover Guilderland
      • Discover Latham and Boght
      • Discover Loudonville
      • Discover Menands
      • Discover Slingerlands
      • Discover Village of Colonie
      • Discover Voorheesville and New Scotland
    • Government
    • Milestones
    • Obituaries
  • Sports
  • The Spot 518
    • Galleries
    • Food and Recipes
  • Hot Spots Calendar
    • Calendar Listings
    • Submit Your Event
  • Opinion
    • Blogs
    • Our Opinion
    • Point of View
    • Your Opinion
  • Family Now
  • Classifieds
    • Employment – Hire Power
    • Services In the Spotlight
    • Classified Listings
    • Advertiser Login
  • Subscribe
    • Subscriber login
    • Give the gift of news
    • Join us – subscribe today
    • Newsletter sign up
    • Renew Subscription
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • Business
      • Spotlight On Business
      • Spotlight on Finance
    • Crime
    • Discover-Towns
      • Discover Coeymans Selkirk and Feura Bush
      • Discover Delmar
      • Discover Glenmont
      • Discover Guilderland
      • Discover Latham and Boght
      • Discover Loudonville
      • Discover Menands
      • Discover Slingerlands
      • Discover Village of Colonie
      • Discover Voorheesville and New Scotland
    • Government
    • Milestones
    • Obituaries
  • Sports
  • The Spot 518
    • Galleries
    • Food and Recipes
  • Hot Spots Calendar
    • Calendar Listings
    • Submit Your Event
  • Opinion
    • Blogs
    • Our Opinion
    • Point of View
    • Your Opinion
  • Family Now
  • Classifieds
    • Employment – Hire Power
    • Services In the Spotlight
    • Classified Listings
    • Advertiser Login
  • Subscribe
    • Subscriber login
    • Give the gift of news
    • Join us – subscribe today
    • Newsletter sign up
    • Renew Subscription
No Result
View All Result
Spotlight News
No Result
View All Result
Home Towns Albany County

UPDATED: Judge dismisses Justice Center’s case against teacher accused of having sex with student

Jim Franco by Jim Franco
March 30, 2017
in Albany County, Bethlehem, Crime, News, Towns
Reading Time: 5 mins read
Judge Thomas Breslin while listening to oral arguments in the case against Marina Viviani (Photo by Jim Franco/Spotlight News)

Judge Thomas Breslin while listening to oral arguments in the case against Marina Viviani (Photo by Jim Franco/Spotlight News)

UPDATE – Aug 3, 2017: An Albany County Judge dismisses another case from the Justice Center citing this case as basis. Click Here for details.

In a decision that could have a dramatic impact on cases brought by the Justice Center for the Protection of People with Special Needs, a judge on Thursday, March 30 tossed the rape charges brought by the state agency against a former teacher at the LaSalle School.

Marina Viviani and sits to the left of her attorney, Michael Pollok, during an appearance in front of Judge Thomas Breslin (photo by Jim Franco/Spotlight News)

Albany County Court Judge Thomas Breslin ruled the only way the Justice Center could prosecute Marina Viviani is if it had permission by District Attorney David Soares, and if Soares maintained oversight and responsibility of the case.

“There is no evidence that the District Attorney has retained ultimate prosecutorial authority and responsibility in this case,” Breslin wrote in a five-page decision (see below.) “Accordingly, this court finds the Justice Center did not have authority to prosecute, and the case must be dismissed.”

In September, 2016, The Justice Center charged Viviani with a host of crimes related to allegations she had sex with a student at the Albany school that serves troubled, adolescent males. The Justice Center then continued prosecuting the case, including bringing it to a grand jury and obtaining an indictment.

Her attorney, Michael Pollok, claimed the state constitution only gives county District Attorneys and the state Attorney General – both answerable to the electorate – the power to prosecute criminal matters. Attorney General Eric Schneiderman signed on, saying the executive order by Gov. Andrew Cuomo creating the Justice Center and the legislative decision to grant it the power to prosecute is unconstitutional for the same reason.

The Justice Center was given “concurrent” authority with the

Justice Center for the Protection of People with Special Needs Deputy Special Prosecutor Jacqueline Kagan (Photo by Jim Franco/Spotlight News)

District Attorneys when it was created by the legislature at the urging of Gov. Andrew Cuomo in 2012, and believes it doesn’t need anyone’s permission to prosecute criminal matters.

Pollok, a solicitor general for the AG’s office, Andrew Ammend, and Jacqueline Kagan, a deputy special prosecutor for the Justice Center, presented oral arguments stating their respective cases to Breslin earlier this month.

Breslin, in his decision, wrote the state statute creating the Justice Center “can pass constitutional muster by reading it to require the District Attorney to maintain ultimate prosecutorial responsibility for the prosecution of any case.”

And, he wrote, there was “no evidence” the Soares maintained that responsibility, if it ever assumed it from the start.

Pollok said his client was “very pleased” and believes the decision is going to have an impact on every case the Justice Center has ever prosecuted.

Judge Thomas Breslin while listening to oral arguments in the case against Marina Viviani (Photo by Jim Franco/Spotlight News)

“This is now the law in Albany County,” he said. “In my opinion, every case brought by the Justice Center in Albany County can and should be reviewed.”

The Justice Center, in a statement, said it is reviewing the decision, considering its options and is not ruling out an appeal.

“The Justice Center believes that the legislature acted within its authority when it created a special prosecutor in the Justice Center,” said spokeswoman Dianne Ward.

In a statement, a spokeswoman for Albany County District Attorney David Soares said the office was just following protocol established by the state Legislature when it created the Justice Center.

“Our office, along with District Attorneys across the state, has understood that the Justice Center for the Protection of People with Special Needs has operated with concurrent jurisdiction to prosecute criminal law violations in state-run facilities since their creation by statutory design under New York state law,” the statement reads.

Since he ruled the Justice Center did not have authority to prosecute, Breslin said the DA’s office could not continue with the Justice Center case against Viviani, but did not explicitly say the DA could start over. The spokeswoman, Cecelia Walsh, said that matter is under review.

Old Cases

Marina Viviani in court earlier this month photo by Jim Franco/Spotlight News)

The decision will likely head to higher courts – first the Appellate Division and then the Court of Appeals, the state’s highest court – but if Breslin’s decision is upheld, it could re-open every case the Justice Center has prosecuted since it’s inception in 2013.

“I do think, if the constitutional issues are not waived, there could be collateral attacks on cases that have already gone through the system,” said Albany Law professor Laurie Shanks. “Looking back is unusual, but a limited exception is when they didn’t have the authority in the first place.”

She said she “absolutely” agrees with Breslin’s ruling, in which he cited a dissenting opinion in a Court of Appeals ruling that did not address the constitutional issues because of technical reasons.

“Prosecuting someone for a crime is one of the most serious things a government can do and must be done strictly in accordance with the constitution and the applicable statutes,” she said. “In this case, the legislature has designated someone who has the authority to prosecute someone and has the same authority as an elected official. You have the danger of any agency being given such authority like the Department of Motor Vehicles prosecuting DWI cases.”

Furthermore, she said, there is the inherent risk to constitutional rights by having more than one entity with the authority to prosecute the same crimes. For example, if the DA doesn’t think there is enough evidence, the Justice Center may have a different opinion and bring charges anyway. Or vice versa.

“The law needs to be re-written to provide a mechanism for Justice Center attorneys to be appointed special prosecutors by the District Attorneys,” Pollok said. “Then it would comply with the state Constitution. There has to be safeguards in place to make sure the DA of the county prosecutes because they and only they are accountable to the people.”

Pending cases

Terry Kindlon, in his capacity as Albany County Chief Public Defender, asked Judge Roger McDonough to dismiss charges against his client, who is accused of sexually abusing a client at Hope House.

“The indictment herein is invalid,” Kindlon cuts to the chase in the first graph of his motion after the introductions. “It was procured not by the Albany County District Attorney nor by the New York State Attorney General but by a so-called ‘special prosecutor’ who, notwithstanding her job title, does not meet the constitutional standard to be a criminal prosecutor but is merely an employee of a state agency called the Justice Center for the Protection of People with Special Needs.”

In December, 2016, the Justice Center charged his client, 29-year-old Nicole Hodgdon, of rape for allegedly having a sex with a person at Hope House to treat drug addiction.

Hope House is certified by the state Office of Alcoholism and Substance Abuse Services and any allegations of abuse or neglect fall under the auspices of the Justice Center, according to the state Legislature.

But, Kindlon, like his wife Shanks and the others above including Breslin, don’t think the Justice Center has the proper authority to unilaterally prosecute anything or anyone.

“The Legislature’s purported appointment of an unelected ‘special prosecutor’ is a nullity,” Kindlon wrote. “It represents an improper attempt to usurp the criminal prosecution duties, powers, and obligations of the constitutional officers specified in the New York State Constitution, i.e., the duly elected Albany County District Attorney and (in certain circumstances) the duly elected Attorney General.”

Kindlon filed his motion to dismiss on March 16, about two weeks before Breslin’s ruling. It’s unclear how many open cases the Justice Center has statewide, or if other attorneys will follow suit.

 

 

 

Marina Viviani Decision and Order 3-30-17 by jfranco17410 on Scribd

Tags: Attorney General Eric SchneidermanDeputy Special Prosecutor Jacqueline KaganDistrict Attorney David SoaresJudge Thomas BreslinJustice Center for the Protection of People with Special NeedsMarina Viviani
ShareTweetShareShare
Previous Post

ASK YOUR DAUGHTER: Pondering the role of advocacy, politics

Next Post

North Colonie School Board opts for the $106.3 million Option B

Leave Comment

Stay Connected with Us

Recent News

Letters to the Editor: Support for beleaguered coach

August 7, 2022

Bond over cooking

August 7, 2022

Steps to beat cooling costs

August 6, 2022
Mason Witkowski, age 13, during the 2021 youth spring turkey season. I Paul Witkowski, father,

This turkey was harvested in Orange County New York

DEC seeks to help to report turkey sightings in August

August 6, 2022

Hot Stories This Week

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Ruth Whitman's grave at Cavalry Cemetery in Glenmont. (Jim Franco/Spotlight News)

UPDATE: Colonie police exhume body of 1959 murder victim

August 2, 2022
Ruth Whitman's grave in the Cavalry Cemetery in Glenmont. (Jim Franco / Spotlight News)

Colonie police to exhume 1959 murder victim

August 1, 2022

Bethlehem awarded 1.5 million grant to build multi-use path along Slingerlands’ Cherry Avenue Extension

August 3, 2022
The Albany County Legislature (Spotlight file photo)

Albany County lifts residency requirement

August 4, 2022

Letters to the Editor: Support for beleaguered coach

August 7, 2022

Bond over cooking

August 7, 2022

Steps to beat cooling costs

August 6, 2022
Mason Witkowski, age 13, during the 2021 youth spring turkey season. I Paul Witkowski, father,

This turkey was harvested in Orange County New York

DEC seeks to help to report turkey sightings in August

August 6, 2022
Spotlight News

Spotlight News, The Spot 518 and Capital District Family Now are divisions of Community Media Group, LLC. Our local offices are located at 341 Delaware Ave, Delmar, NY 12054. You can contact us at 518.439.4949.

Browse

Follow Us

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact the Editor
  • Employment
  • Our Team
  • Privacy & Policy

© 2021 Community Media Group, LLC - 341 Delaware Ave. Delmar, NY 12054. 518.439.4949

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • Spotlight On Business
    • Spotlight on Finance
  • Sports
  • The Spot 518
  • Hot Spots Calendar
  • Opinion
  • Subscribe
  • Newsletter Sign Up
  • Log In
  • Classifieds
    • Advertiser Login
  • Service Directory

© 2021 Community Media Group, LLC - 341 Delaware Ave. Delmar, NY 12054. 518.439.4949